You're in a mediation room in Los Angeles, and the dispute has already consumed more time, money, and patience than you expected. Maybe you're a Koreatown tenant arguing over repairs, a Downtown vendor waiting on an unpaid invoice, or a San Fernando Valley contractor defending a change-order claim. The mediator asks whether you're prepared to negotiate, but you're worried that “good faith” means you must accept an offer you believe is unfair.
It doesn't. Negotiation in good faith is usually a process duty, not a guarantee of settlement. You must participate, stay open to evaluating options, and follow the rules that apply to your agreement, mediation, or case. You generally don't have to concede, disclose privileged material, or accept the other side's number.
Table of Contents
- What Negotiation in Good Faith Actually Means
- How the Duty Evolved from Labor Law to Civil Mediation
- Core Duties in a Los Angeles Civil Mediation
- Hard Bargaining Is Not the Same as Bad Faith
- Real-World Signs of Bad Faith in LA Civil Disputes
- Remedies When the Other Side Fails to Negotiate Properly
- Your Good-Faith Checklist Before and During Mediation
What Negotiation in Good Faith Actually Means
The duty concerns conduct, not surrender
In a Los Angeles civil mediation, good faith starts with practical behavior. You arrive on time, understand the dispute, bring the information needed to evaluate it, and make sure the person attending can communicate with the actual decision-maker. You respond to proposals rather than allowing them to disappear into silence. You listen to the mediator's questions and address the other side's position, even when your answer remains no.
A party can hold a firm position and still participate properly. A tenant might insist that unsafe conditions caused substantial disruption. A landlord might maintain that the claimed repairs were completed or that some damages aren't supported. A contractor might reject a broad demand while offering a narrower resolution tied to documented work. The question is whether the party engaged with the process, not whether the party gave the opponent the result it wanted.
The specific source of the obligation matters. It may arise from a contract clause, an agreement to mediate, a court order, or rules governing the proceeding. In some disputes, the relevant agreement requires the parties to attempt good-faith negotiation before filing suit. In others, the parties argue over whether their conduct breached a contractual promise to negotiate at all. The legal standard can vary by jurisdiction and context, so a party shouldn't assume that a general moral idea answers a specific legal question.
What a mediator can observe
A mediator isn't deciding liability in the way a judge or jury would. Still, the mediator can observe whether each side is participating meaningfully. Useful indicators include:
- Preparation: The party understands its claims, defenses, damages, and settlement authority.
- Candor: The party gives accurate answers and doesn't knowingly misstate material facts or positions.
- Responsiveness: The party reviews proposals and provides timely reactions.
- Open-minded evaluation: The party considers alternatives and offers ideas of its own, while preserving the right not to settle.
Authoritative guidance describes good-faith participation as approaching the process with an open mind, including a willingness to consider the other side's options and propose solutions without giving up self-interest or the right to refuse agreement. This discussion of good-faith mediation participation is useful because it focuses on observable actions rather than a party's claimed intentions.
Practical rule: You can say no to a settlement. You can't use the mediation as a performance while refusing to engage with the substance.
The record later used by a court may include correspondence, scheduling messages, written proposals, declarations, and evidence about who attended and what authority that person had. Confidentiality rules can restrict what a party may disclose about settlement discussions, so document preservation and legal advice should be handled carefully. The safest approach is to participate sincerely, follow the governing agreement, and ask counsel what can lawfully be documented or presented.
How the Duty Evolved from Labor Law to Civil Mediation
The modern legal history of good faith negotiation begins in U.S. labor law. The National Labor Relations Act of 1935 imposed a duty to bargain collectively in good faith. The Taft-Hartley amendments in 1947 extended the obligation to unions as well as employers. Under Section 8(d), the duty includes meeting at reasonable times and conferring about wages, hours, and other employment terms, while requiring neither side to accept a particular proposal.
The earlier Railway Labor Act had already used a similar “every reasonable effort” standard in dispute resolution during the 1920-era period. These milestones show how good faith moved from an ethical expectation into a legal duty evaluated through conduct. A party's private claim that it was sincere isn't enough if its actions reveal refusal to meet, refusal to exchange relevant information, or a pattern of superficial participation. The historical discussion of these labor-law milestones provides the foundation for understanding that shift.

The commercial-law expansion
Good faith later appeared in broader contract settings, including disputes involving settlement promises, covenants to negotiate, and agreements to agree. Canada's Supreme Court took a notable step in Bhasin v. Hrynew, recognizing good faith as a “general organizing principle” of Canadian contract law and recognizing a common-law duty of honest performance. The Canadian example matters here as comparative background, not as a substitute for California law. It illustrates how courts have increasingly examined honesty and process in commercial relationships instead of treating good faith as a purely abstract aspiration.
Canadian federal public-sector labor law also shows how a broad duty can become procedural. After notice to bargain, the parties must meet and begin bargaining in good faith within 20 days, unless they agree otherwise. The Canadian statutory timing rule demonstrates the difference between a general principle and a specific procedural requirement.
California civil mediation operates in a different legal environment from collective bargaining. Even so, the behavioral lens carries over. Courts and neutrals may ask whether a party treated the process as genuine, answered relevant questions, evaluated proposals, and avoided conduct designed only to frustrate resolution. The modern LA civil standard is therefore best understood as a hybrid, shaped by labor-law expectations but applied to contracts, court proceedings, and private dispute-resolution agreements.
Core Duties in a Los Angeles Civil Mediation
A party doesn't satisfy good faith merely by occupying a chair. The mediator typically watches for a pattern of conduct showing that the party came to participate, evaluate, and communicate.

Attendance with actual authority
A West LA business owner shouldn't send an employee who must place repeated calls before discussing settlement. The representative doesn't need unlimited authority or permission to accept every demand. The person should, however, understand the authority available, know when additional approval is required, and have a workable way to obtain that approval during the session.
If the decision-maker can't attend, tell the mediator and opposing counsel in advance. A remote appearance, scheduled availability, or agreed authority protocol may solve the problem. A surprise absence is different from a disclosed limitation. The second can be managed. The first can make the session look ceremonial.
Meaningful participation
Participation means more than repeating a prepared position. In a Downtown contract dispute, the vendor might explain why it believes the invoice is due, identify the records supporting that view, and respond to the buyer's concerns about performance. The buyer may disagree, but should address the actual issues instead of changing subjects whenever the mediator asks for detail.
The explanation of how mediation works describes the practical role of joint discussion and private caucuses. Those formats give parties room to speak directly, test assumptions privately, and explore terms that may not appear in the pleadings.
Disclosure of relevant information
Good faith doesn't require disclosure of privileged communications or every document in your possession. It does require honest handling of information that the parties have agreed to exchange or that the mediator needs to evaluate a proposal. Withholding a central repair record until after mediation can prevent a meaningful conversation. Providing a clear explanation for a disputed document, including a confidentiality concern, is more constructive than pretending the issue doesn't exist.
Consideration of offers
A party may reject an offer because the amount, release, payment schedule, tax treatment, or nonmonetary term is unacceptable. Consideration means the party evaluates the proposal and communicates a reasoned response. Sometimes the response is a counteroffer. Sometimes it's a request for missing information. Sometimes it is a firm rejection that explains why movement isn't possible.
A hard position is not evidence of bad faith by itself. Refusing to examine the path between the positions may be.
The mediator may record observations about attendance, authority, responsiveness, and unresolved barriers. Opposing counsel may preserve proposal letters, emails, and scheduling communications. Good faith is judged across the process, so one awkward exchange usually matters less than a repeated pattern of evasion or engagement.
A short video can also help first-time participants understand the setting and sequence of a mediation session:
Hard Bargaining Is Not the Same as Bad Faith
Good faith doesn't require agreement, concessions, or a particular settlement number. The National Labor Relations Board explains that bargaining parties must meet and confer in good faith, but the duty doesn't require either side to agree to a proposal. The NLRB's explanation of bargaining in good faith is a helpful reminder that process and outcome are separate questions.

Firm positions can be lawful
Consider three LA disputes:
- In a Westlake tenant habitability dispute, the tenant demands compensation and a broad release. The landlord says the demand exceeds the documented loss and offers a narrower release. Both sides explain their positions and answer questions.
- In a Downtown commercial lease buyout, the tenant refuses to pay the requested amount because it disputes the landlord's interpretation of the lease. The tenant still reviews payment schedules, proposes a structured exit, and identifies the terms it could accept.
- In a San Fernando Valley premises liability case, the defendant holds to a firm valuation because it disputes notice and causation. Counsel tests the medical records, responds to counterarguments, and doesn't misstate the evidence.
Those parties may be difficult negotiators. They may anchor low, insist on broad protections, reject “retail” damages, or say that litigation remains preferable. None of that alone proves bad faith.
Process attacks cross the line
The concern changes when conduct targets the mediation itself rather than the disputed merits. Examples include:
- Presenting terms that the attending representative never had authority to discuss.
- Refusing to read or evaluate a proposal.
- Creating urgency through a deadline that has no legitimate basis.
- Concealing a material issue while asking the other side to negotiate around an incomplete picture.
- Attending only to postpone a hearing or create the appearance of compliance.
A party doesn't have to make a concession merely because the mediator believes it would be sensible. It should, however, engage with the proposal and explain the obstacle.
Use this room-level decision rule: Can you identify a legitimate dispute-based reason for your position, and can you show that you evaluated the other side's response? If yes, you may be bargaining hard. If your conduct is designed to prevent any meaningful exchange, the risk of a bad-faith finding rises.
Real-World Signs of Bad Faith in LA Civil Disputes
Mediators don't need dramatic misconduct to recognize a problem. The pattern often appears in small, repeated choices that make meaningful negotiation impossible.
Five patterns that deserve attention
The absent decision-maker. A representative arrives without authority, calls the owner only after every proposal, and then disappears for long stretches. That may be acceptable if the limitation was disclosed and the owner remains available. It looks worse when the representative was presented as having authority and the decision-maker cannot be reached.
The frozen demand. A party says it is “interested in resolution” but repeats a confidential demand without answering questions, identifying terms it might trade, or reacting to factual developments. A fixed number isn't bad faith. The problem is using settlement language while refusing substantive engagement.
The late document surprise. In an employment dispute, one side waits until after mediation to produce central materials that had been requested and should have informed the discussion. The mediator may not decide whether the withholding was improper, but the timing can support an argument that the session wasn't meaningful.
The timed stonewall. In a Boyle Heights HOA nuisance dispute, a party delays responses to straightforward proposals until a hearing date approaches, then claims the other side never offered a workable path. Delay can be strategic and lawful. Delay paired with silence, shifting explanations, and no evaluation looks different.
The prepared walkout. Counsel announces a “final offer” before the mediator has met with both sides, tested the factual assumptions, or explored nonmonetary options. A final offer can be legitimate. A scripted exit that occurs before participation may suggest the session was never intended to function as negotiation.
How the line gets recorded
A post-mediation evaluation may describe a party as having participated, participated with limitations, or failed to engage meaningfully. The wording matters because later motion practice usually depends on concrete facts, not a general statement that someone “seemed difficult.”
| Behavior Observed | Hard Bargaining or Bad Faith? | What Tipped the Call |
|---|---|---|
| Refusing a settlement number after reviewing the damages records | Hard bargaining | The party explained its valuation and answered questions |
| Sending a representative without disclosed authority | Borderline or bad faith | The decision-maker couldn't be reached and the session stalled |
| Rejecting a broad release but proposing a narrower one | Hard bargaining | The party offered a workable alternative |
| Repeating a demand without responding to new information | Borderline | The party never addressed the factual change |
| Leaving before substantive discussion despite a mediation requirement | Bad faith risk | The conduct suggested attendance was only symbolic |
A mediator's notes remain subject to confidentiality and applicable evidence rules. Parties shouldn't assume they can introduce every statement from the session later. The more reliable evidence often concerns logistics, written proposals, authority disclosures, and communications outside the protected discussion.
Remedies When the Other Side Fails to Negotiate Properly
The remedy depends on the source of the duty and the evidence available. A court may treat a contractual mediation promise differently from a court-ordered settlement conference or a labor-law obligation. Before accusing the other side, identify the exact clause, order, rule, or statute you believe was violated.
Start with a clean record
Preserve time-stamped proposal letters, scheduling messages, attendance confirmations, document requests, and follow-up emails. Ask the mediator what procedural documentation is available, but don't pressure the mediator to disclose protected communications. Settlement confidentiality can limit declarations and motions, so counsel should review the evidence before filing.
A party may seek relief connected to a contractual obligation to mediate, including an order requiring compliance where the agreement and applicable law support that remedy. It may also seek targeted discovery about authority, scheduling, or exchanged materials. A motion should show the specific conduct, why it mattered, and what remedy is legally available, rather than describing the session as unproductive.
Match the remedy to the breach
Depending on the case, possible steps include:
- Contract enforcement: Ask the court to enforce a mediation or negotiation clause when its language and governing law support enforcement.
- Cost or fee consequences: Review fee-shifting provisions, settlement discounts, and contractual consequences triggered by nonparticipation.
- Case-management relief: Request appropriate scheduling or compliance relief when a party used delay to interfere with the proceeding.
- Evidentiary protection: Seek limits on the use of settlement communications when confidentiality rules apply, rather than trying to use protected statements offensively.
- Sanctions analysis: Evaluate whether the conduct fits the requirements of an applicable sanctions statute or procedural rule, including Code of Civil Procedure provisions that may govern mediation compliance.
The article what happens after mediation fails provides practical context for moving a case forward when no settlement results. Failure to settle isn't itself proof of bad faith. The stronger claim is that the other side failed to perform a required process.
Keep expectations realistic
Courts rarely force parties to accept a settlement or manufacture agreement where none exists. Remedies more often focus on compliance, costs, scheduling pressure, or contractual consequences. A judge will usually want contemporaneous evidence showing what happened, not only an after-the-fact characterization from a disappointed negotiator.
Your Good-Faith Checklist Before and During Mediation
Use the checklist as protection, not theater. It helps you meet your own obligations and gives you a disciplined way to identify whether the other side is engaging with the process.
Before the session
Read the governing language. Review the mediation clause, court order, stipulation, or demand that allegedly requires negotiation. Look for requirements about notice, attendance, timing, authority, confidentiality, and costs.
Confirm decision-making authority. Identify who can approve settlement terms and how that person will participate. If approval must come from an insurer, board, owner, or other principal, arrange availability before the session.
Organize the factual file. Gather the contract, invoices, photographs, repair records, medical materials, pleadings, correspondence, and damages support relevant to the dispute. Separate privileged material from documents you may be able to share.
Set a reasoned negotiation range. Decide what terms matter beyond money, such as releases, payment timing, repairs, confidentiality, dismissal language, or future conduct. Write down the factual and legal reasons for your preferred range so frustration doesn't control the session.
The mediation preparation guidance can help you organize the practical work before appearing.
During the session
- Arrive ready to participate: Be punctual, reachable, and prepared to explain your position in plain language.
- Speak candidly with the mediator: Identify weaknesses, missing information, authority limits, and the terms that could change your assessment.
- Respond to proposals: Don't let an offer expire through silence. Ask questions or explain why you reject it.
- Counter when appropriate: You don't owe a concession, but a counterproposal can show that you're evaluating the available paths.
- Track the exchange: Keep a private timeline of offers, responses, document requests, and agreed follow-up steps.
- Respect confidentiality: Don't assume that your notes or the mediator's statements can later be filed with the court.
After the session, preserve permitted correspondence and send a careful follow-up confirming logistics, deadlines, or agreed next steps. Don't turn a failed mediation into a public argument about who was unreasonable. If a later motion becomes necessary, a clear record of participation will usually serve you better than heated labels.
Before you leave the room, ask yourself: Did I understand the proposal, explain my response, and give the other side a fair chance to understand mine?
A neutral mediation service can provide structured joint sessions, private caucuses, intake screening, and preparation support, but it isn't a substitute for legal advice. Mediation & Negotiation Services (M&N) offers those civil mediation and negotiation services for Los Angeles disputes, with resources intended to help parties prepare for structured settlement discussions. Visit Mediation & Negotiation Services (M&N) to review the available process and request information about your dispute.
Mediation & Negotiation Services (M&N) can help organize a structured conversation, private caucuses, and preparation for a Los Angeles civil dispute where good-faith participation matters. Visit Mediation & Negotiation Services (M&N) to review the service and begin the intake process.




